Ideology or Real Results: What Matters More?

When you have never done something before, what are your chances of succeeding on the first try? Before ever getting behind the wheel of a car, would you presume to lecture Lewis Hamilton on how to win a Formula One race? If you have not played rugby since primary school, would you confidently tell Rassie Erasmus what needs to change in his game plan?

 

As absurd as it sounds to act as a strategic adviser in a field where you have zero track record, this is precisely how we govern our economy. Far too many of our economic policies are entrusted to individuals who have only ever been employees, never employers. In reality, we should be taking our cue from Lewis Hamilton on the track, and trusting Rassie to steer us toward victory on the field.

 

Today, the futures of more than 8.5 million unemployed South Africans—and their families—hang in the balance. When we factor in dependants, roughly 27 to 32 million people are directly impacted by this crisis. Children are going hungry, malnutrition is causing irreversible stunting, dignity is being eroded, and violent crime increasingly looks like a viable means of survival to the desperate. Are we really so callous that we would rather protect political ideology than deliver the real results needed to end this suffering?

 

We must stop allowing inexperienced voices to dictate our future with ideology and false hope. Delivering prosperity for all requires reliable, proven performance. We must appoint leaders with a demonstrated track record of success in the task at hand, minimising the risk of failure.

 

Business is the engine that creates wealth for the entire economy. It pays corporate taxes, salaries, and suppliers—all of which generate the tax revenue that funds government. If business does not grow, the nation stalls. Business is quite literally the goose that lays the golden eggs, yet poor policy decisions are steadily killing our geese.

 

A business owner creates jobs and understands the exact conditions required to expand or shrink a workforce. Employees do not. While everyone is entitled to an opinion, running an economy is not a popularity contest; a popular vote will never produce a sound business strategy. Employees have never risked their own capital or felt the sting of commercial failure. In business, every mistake comes directly off the net profit—straight out of the owner’s pocket. That skin in the game forces a business owner to learn fast and focus ruthlessly on what actually works. When you have never created a single private-sector job, how can you dictate job-creation policy?

 

After more than thirty years of democracy, it is time to set ideological debates aside and focus relentlessly on real job creation. Let business play a leading role in pulling South Africa out of its stagnant growth quagmire, and chart a path toward the rapid prosperity our country is so capable of achieving—if only we stop shooting ourselves in the foot.

 

John Lawson, CEO of the Cape Chamber of Commerce and Industry